Science is the poetry of Nature.

Contributing Authors

Solid or Liquid? Physicists Redefine States of Matter

Why can you stand on a glacier but not the ocean?

The answer seems simple enough: Liquids flow. Solids don’t. The atoms in liquids can slosh around. In solids, they fall lockstep into a crystal lattice. A crystal’s endlessly repeating pattern is so stable that it takes a considerable infusion of energy to make the atoms break rank. Or so physics textbooks say.

But this long-accepted explanation for the rigidity of solids fails to account for quasicrystals — bizarre solids first discovered in the lab in 1982 and found in nature in 2009. Atoms in quasicrystals are arranged in patterns that never repeat, but the material is nonetheless rigid. So is glass, an amorphous mass of stationary atoms that behaves like a solid but, upon closer inspection, looks more like a liquid frozen in time.

“Glasses have been around for thousands of years,” said Daniel Stein, a professor of physics and mathematics at New York University. “Chemists understand them. Engineers understand them. From the point of view of physics, we don’t understand them. Why are they rigid?”

Even crystalline solids such as glaciers resist categorization, as their atoms can flow, albeit very slowly. And sometimes the reverse also seems true: The ocean feels rigid if you jump onto it from a tall enough glacier. What, then, is the difference between a liquid and a solid?

Physicists in France and the United States are proposing new answers to this fundamental question. As outlined in a March article in the Notices of the American Mathematical Society, the researchers have identified two characteristics of materials that dramatically change form at the intersections of temperature and pressure where liquids turn solid. These characteristics, the physicists say, could define the difference between the two states of matter.

Charles Radin, a mathematical physicist at the University of Texas at Austin, and his former student, David Aristoff, now a mathematician at the University of Minnesota, argue that the main difference between liquids and solids is the way they respond to shear, or twisting forces. Liquids barely resist shear and can easily be sloshed, whereas solids — regardless of whether they are crystals, quasicrystals or glass — resist attempts to change their shape.

The liquid-solid phase transition, Radin and Aristoff reason, should therefore be marked by the “shear response” of a material jumping from zero to a positive value. And they observed just such a jump for a two-dimensional model material, in which atoms are represented by disks: At low densities corresponding to the material’s liquid phase, it showed no response to shear, but when the disks were densely packed, like the atoms in a solid, shear caused the material to expand. “The crossover where it shows this effect is exactly the density where the system becomes crystalline,” Radin said. “We propose this as a different way of understanding what a solid is.”

Full Article

  1. amanz reblogged this from scinerds
  2. federalgovernment reblogged this from scinerds
  3. 2chainzlegit reblogged this from scinerds
  4. peacefreak97 reblogged this from scinerds
  5. tasty-salamanders reblogged this from procyonvulpecula
  6. deemmzee reblogged this from scinerds
  7. lisah71 reblogged this from scinerds
  8. invertthesnow reblogged this from hiddles-kun
  9. polymethodic reblogged this from ajora
  10. ajora reblogged this from thescienceofreality
  11. teckdeck2008 reblogged this from anengineersaspect
  12. anengineersaspect reblogged this from rawritskendrick
  13. titles-for-tangents reblogged this from hiddles-kun
  14. hiddles-kun reblogged this from thescienceofreality
  15. ohmisterpoliceman reblogged this from thescienceofreality
  16. tosstwo reblogged this from thescienceofreality
  17. theokid reblogged this from queerts
  18. lookforwardletgo reblogged this from thescienceofreality
  19. politicaldilettante reblogged this from thescienceofreality
  20. michaelvandenberg reblogged this from thescienceofreality
  21. theromanticsadist reblogged this from catnapqueen
  22. mmartist91 reblogged this from thescienceofreality
  23. altered-thinking reblogged this from keymondiartiste
  24. sanarues reblogged this from aceknightxvx
  25. aceknightxvx reblogged this from resident-tofu